我们在做项目时,可能会遇到这样的需求,比如判断,1,2,3,33,22,123, 中是否存在,3,。
var str=",1,2,3,33,22,123,";
一般有几种方式:
1、str.IndexOf(",3,")>=0
2、str.Contains(",3,")
有可能我们不用字符串而用List来存,判断list中是否存在3
var list = str.Split(',').ToList();
3、list.Contains("3");
4、List.Any(t=>t=="3");
接下来就验证一下上面4种方案究竟哪种效率最高?
public void Test() { var str = "article.add,article.update,article.delete,article.view," + "category.add,category.update,category.delete,category.view," + "user.add,user.update,user.delete,user.view," + "role.add,role.update,role.delete,role.view," + "news.add,news.update,news.delete,news.view," + "category.add,category.update,category.delete,category.view," + "Threading.add,Threading.update,Threading.delete,Threading.view," + "System.add,System.update,System.delete,System.view," + "Generic.add,Generic.update,Generic.delete,Generic.view," + "Collections.add,Collections.update,Collections.delete,Collections.view," + "Tasks.add,Tasks.update,Tasks.delete,Tasks.view," + "CslApp.add,CslApp.update,CslApp.delete,CslApp.view"; var list = str.Split(',').ToList(); var str1 = "Tasks2.view"; //这里查询一个不存在的字符串,这样更费时,如果字符串存在,话费的时间要少些。 var count = 100000; Stopwatch sw = new Stopwatch(); sw.Start(); //耗时巨大的代码 for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) { if (str.Contains(str1)) { } } sw.Stop(); TimeSpan ts = sw.Elapsed; Console.WriteLine("string.contains总共花费{0}ms.", ts.TotalMilliseconds); Stopwatch sw2 = new Stopwatch(); sw2.Start(); //耗时巨大的代码 for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) { if (list.Contains(str1)) { } } sw2.Stop(); TimeSpan ts2 = sw2.Elapsed; Console.WriteLine("List.Contains总共花费{0}ms.", ts2.TotalMilliseconds); Stopwatch sw3 = new Stopwatch(); sw3.Start(); //耗时巨大的代码 for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) { if (list.Any(t=>t == str1)) { } } sw3.Stop(); TimeSpan ts3 = sw3.Elapsed; Console.WriteLine("List.Any总共花费{0}ms.", ts3.TotalMilliseconds); Stopwatch sw4 = new Stopwatch(); sw4.Start(); //耗时巨大的代码 for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) { if (str.IndexOf(str1)>=0) { } } sw4.Stop(); TimeSpan ts4 = sw4.Elapsed; Console.WriteLine("string.IndexOf总共花费{0}ms.", ts4.TotalMilliseconds); }
这里分别循环十万次来测试,得到的结果:
可以看出,IndexOf >=0这种方式简直是灾难性的存在,
效率最高的是将字符串转成List在用List.Contains判断,
List.Any查询效率都远不如string.Contains和List.Contains。
下面运行100万次的结果,由于indexof效率实在太差太费时间,就去掉了这个判断,
可见,转换成List在用list.Contains判断效率是最高的。